Brooding Over Bagels

on
Wednesday, January 21, 2026

One of my co-workers enjoys baking and keeps me up to date on what desserts are popular on TikTok.  Examples: Vietnamese Coffee Swirl Brownies and Ina Garten's Brownie PuddingHow fabulous is that?  When I'm in a baking rut she inspires me to branch out and make something I wouldn't normally attempt.  Most recently, she's inspired me to make bagels and I think I'm going to go for it this weekend - naturally leavened, of course.  It's too difficult to bake during the week with having little ones and working full-time.  Although, I did manage to bake two loaves of sourdough on Monday night after they proofed all day.  They didn't turn out as well as the last batch and I think it's because I didn't let the dough bulk ferment enough.  

Which brings me to my question: What's the best bagel you've EVER had?  Have you even had a really, really good bagel?  I feel like truly good bagels are few and far between.  The best bagels I've ever had were from St-Viateur Bagel shop in Montreal, Canada.  Montreal-style bagels are smaller, thinner, hand-rolled, wood-fired, and a little crunchier than New-York Style bagels.  When I was a flight attendant I would always stop by St-Viateur in the airport for a delicious sesame bagel with salted butter.  Those bagels made layovers in cold, snowy Montreal a little more tolerable.  Paired with a hot Tim Horton's coffee?  Get out of here. 

I had to dig through my Instagram to find a picture of a Montreal bagel I had and this was the best I could find from 2016.  I mean, we are sharing photos from 2016, right?  Apparently I had a smoked meat bagel this particular time.  Not the most enticing picture, I admit.  I swear, they're good!  Side note - why did I post a picture of every Bloody Mary I drank and why did I drink so many?  Oh my gosh, my sodium levels must have been through the roof.

Another good bagel spot - Black Seed Bagels in Manhattan.  This one had sprouts and beautiful watermelon radish.  

What's your go-to bagel recipe?  I'm thinking maybe I'll try one of these:

Sourdough Montreal Style Bagels

Montreal Style Bagel Recipe
Sourdough Sesame Montreal Bagels

Be First to Post Comment !
Post a Comment